User Friction & Site Performance Blog | Blue Triangle

What Happens When Your Homepage Becomes Just Data for Someone Else's Chatbot?

Written by Chuck Moxley | Jun 11, 2025 12:00:02 AM

Imagine this: It's 2029. A customer just spent $500 with your brand. But they never saw your homepage. Never clicked an ad. Never browsed your site. A chatbot handled the entire transaction in 30 seconds.

Sound futuristic? It's already starting.

In this week's episode of The Frictionless Experience, Nick Paladino and I explored what the rise of AI shopping means for brands—and the seismic shift e-commerce teams need to brace for.

From Destination to Dataset

Let's start with the scary part.

Your website, the one you've spent years optimizing, may soon stop being a destination. Instead, it becomes a data source—fuel for someone else's AI.

The homepage, product detail pages, and cart flow could become irrelevant if customers never visit them. As Nick said:

It's not just a theory. It's already happening in small ways.

How We Shop: The Split That AI Needs to Bridge

Nick and I realized during our conversation that we couldn't be more different in how we shop.

Nick is the classic no-nonsense buyer. "I need something, and the first result I want to buy because I want to be in, out, and back to whatever I'm doing," he said. If a bot can give him a "very wife-approved version" of a citronella tiki torch for his backyard, he's sold.

Me? I'm the opposite. I agonize over every purchase—yes, even greeting cards. If I was buying the tiki torch that Nick mentioned buying on a whim, I would have to go read the reviews. Almost every purchase I make, I spend a lot of time researching.

The future of AI shopping depends on bots being able to satisfy both types of buyers. Can they streamline the experience for Nick while still providing enough detail, comparison, and trust signals for someone like me?

When AI Gets It Wrong

Nick tested this with a watch search.

He wanted a hybrid—a dress watch with the rugged features of a sports watch. So he asked ChatGPT to help him find one.

At first, it seemed promising. "It was providing me with links to stores with various different watches of all sorts of prices," he said. But as the prompts got more specific, the results went off the rails.

"At some point, it ended up generating fake watches for me.. Like Roulin instead of Rolex, Hamtide instead of Hublot," Nick said. "Just an image of fake watches. They weren't real at all".

When the bot hallucinated, it didn't just break the experience—it killed the trust.

That's the tightrope AI will need to walk. Get it wrong, and you lose the shopper. Get it right, and suddenly, the homepage, PDPs, product photos, and carefully crafted copy become background noise.

Bots Are Coming—Will They Be Yours?

If you're an e-commerce operator, here's the uncomfortable truth: AI shopping doesn't mean your brand disappears. But it might mean you no longer control the experience.

We talked about how Walmart is exploring schema markup and structured data to make their product pages more "readable" to bots. But they're also exploring building their own bot that knows a customer's preferences and weekly grocery list and could shop autonomously.

That kind of first-party AI experience could create loyalty beyond the brand website. "That actually reminds me of the promise of... smart refrigerators that would identify the products in your refrigerator and then tell you when you were low," Nick said.

It's about utility now. Not UX.

From SEO to GEO: Training for the Next Generation

You've heard of SEO. Now meet GEO: Generative Engine Optimization.

"Are they calling SEO for AI now? I saw GEO," Nick joked. "Generative Engine Optimization. That's such a lame answer, but fine".

Lame or not, it matters. Brands must start treating their content not just as something for people—but as structured training material for bots.

That means ensuring your product data is discoverable, well-tagged, and consistently described across platforms. It means testing whether your brand and products show up when someone asks a bot for a recommendation.

Because if you're not showing up? You don't exist in that experience.

Losing the Add-to-Cart Moment

AI may be about to sever the emotional core of e-commerce: the exploration phase.

Think about all the moments brands have designed: the cross-sells, the pop-ups, the curated landing pages, and the storytelling. All of that disappears when the transaction happens in a minimalist chat window.

"When I go to any website, I get all of the extra frills now because there's some product manager who has justified that this helps with the conversion rate," Nick said. "And I don't want all that. I just want to focus on my goal and my goal alone".

He even showed me his minimalist phone theme—no notifications, no distractions. Just purpose.

That mindset is where AI shopping thrives.

What Should You Do Now?

Look, we're not saying this change happens overnight. Even today, 80% of purchases still happen in-store. But like any transformation—mobile, social, delivery apps—early adoption wins.

Here's what I'd do if I were in your shoes:

  1. Audit how your products show up in generative search. Use tools to test your visibility in AI results and fix gaps in structured data.
  2. Start adapting your product content for machines, not just humans. Bots can't "feel" a story but can read specs, schemas, reviews, and signals.
  3. Explore partnerships or tech that enables direct checkout within bots. Shopify already plans to embed Shop Pay directly into chat.
  4. Ask the tough question: Would a bot know how to shop from you? If not, you've got work to do.

Final Thought: The New Loyalty Loop

What happens to brand loyalty in a world where bots mediate shopping decisions?

"Do you now move over to Grok3 because your brand's loyalty exists there?" Nick asked. "That, to me, is a bigger complication."

Because once loyalty transfers to the bot, not the brand, the rules change. Permanently.

If this episode made you rethink your homepage strategy, you're not alone. Ultimately, the future may not be about building better websites. It may be about building a better relationship with the bots that shop for us.